Key takeaways:
- A jury in Ocala found Hall guilty of kidnapping and first-degree murder and he was sentenced to life in prison.
- Exelby was reported missing on Oct. 12, 2025, and her body was found buried in Florida five days later.
- Prosecutors said Hall exploited Exelby’s mental illness; his attorney argued that she had taken her own life.
A Florida jury has found Dwain Hall guilty of kidnapping and murdering Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old British woman he had contacted on a fetish website and convinced to travel to the United States. Hall, 54, was sentenced to life in prison after the unanimous verdict Friday in Ocala.
Exelby, from the Portsmouth area of England, was reported missing from her home on Oct. 12, 2025. Investigators found her body buried in Marion County, Florida, five days later. Prosecutors said Hall stabbed her to death.
The jury heard that Exelby had struggled with mental illness and had posted online about wanting someone to end her life. Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt said Hall had met her on a now-defunct website and “manipulated her for years.”
“He targeted her because of her mental illness and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure,” Berndt told the court. She said Hall killed Exelby after getting her alone, thousands of miles from home, then buried her body.
Hall, whose online username was Alpha Sadist, demanded $4,000 to kill Exelby, the BBC reported, citing evidence presented at trial. The jury was told that Exelby’s consent would not be a defense to first-degree murder and that coerced submission did not amount to consent.
Hall had pleaded not guilty to kidnapping and first-degree murder. His attorney, Junior Barrett, argued in closing that Exelby had taken her own life, The Guardian reported, citing The Times. “The fact he did not stop her from killing herself does not make it murder,” Barrett said.
According to The Guardian, authorities said Hall picked Exelby up at Gainesville airport after she arrived in Florida in October 2025 and drove her to an Airbnb rental. Investigators examined email, phone and social media records to trace his movements. They also found transactions on Exelby’s bank cards and a video of her on Hall’s phone, the newspaper reported. The prosecution presented 93 pieces of evidence and called 30 witnesses.
The BBC reported that police traced Hall through an attempted use of Exelby’s credit card by the roadside assistance company he owned.
After the verdict, Exelby’s sister, Gemma Isaj, said: “A vulnerable person was preyed upon. A beautiful soul was taken. Our lives will never be the same again.” Isaj said the family would continue to fight for mental health in Exelby’s name.
Exelby’s brother, Barry Wilton, addressed Hall directly: “You had her life in your hands. You had the opportunity to save her, but instead you preyed on her vulnerabilities and you took her from us.”
Be First to Comment