Key takeaways:
- The planned hub would accept migrants who have exhausted their legal avenues to remain in the five EU countries.
- The Dutch government says the first phase will transfer only single men; AFP was told a pilot could accommodate about 100 people.
- Forty-seven aid, trade union and rights groups urged the governments to abandon the plan over human rights concerns.
Five European Union countries plan to send migrants who have no legal right to stay to a return hub in Rwanda from 2027, a proposal aimed at increasing deportations that has drawn warnings from human rights groups.
Germany, Denmark, Austria, Greece and the Netherlands announced the plan on Monday. Negotiations with Rwanda are continuing, Al Jazeera reported. The hub would accept people who have exhausted their legal avenues to remain in the five countries. If they cannot be returned to their country of origin, they could instead be transferred to Rwanda.
Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said those transferred would be able “to voluntarily return to the countries of origin, integrate into Rwandan society or relocate to another destination where they have the legal right to reside, according to their preference”. People who settle in Rwanda would have the right of residence and access to education, healthcare, work and the legal system, according to the BBC.
The Dutch government said the first phase would involve “only return single men”. The Netherlands would focus on people whose countries of origin are in the same region as Rwanda. Diplomatic sources told AFP that the hub could initially operate as a pilot for about 100 people, with each country potentially sending about 20.
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen called the proposal a “game changer”. “We will break down the business model of human smugglers. We will take back control of our borders and we will remove the incentives for illegal migration,” she said. At a press conference in Vienna, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said the countries wanted to ease pressure on European asylum systems and stop traffickers arranging deadly Mediterranean crossings.
The five countries say the plan complies with EU and international law. It follows an EU reform allowing return hubs outside the bloc, according to the BBC. Biruta said Rwanda would provide a “safe, legal and dignified solution for migrants”. Asked how their rights would be protected, he said there would be independent monitoring and cooperation with the UN refugee agency, Al Jazeera reported.
Rights groups dispute that the countries can guarantee migrants’ safety. In a joint statement reported by Al Jazeera, 47 aid, trade union and rights organisations urged the governments to abandon the proposal, saying it risked serious human rights violations without achieving its deterrence goal. Human Rights Watch researcher Clementine de Montjoye cited Rwanda’s record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention and ill-treatment in detention, as well as its support for armed rebels in neighbouring Democratic Republic of Congo.
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights has said any country hosting a return hub must respect fundamental rights and must not receive people who face a serious risk of persecution there. It also said unaccompanied children should not be sent to such hubs; the Dutch government said they would not be transferred under this plan.
The proposal differs from Britain’s abandoned Rwanda scheme, which would have sent people there to have asylum claims processed. Germany’s interior minister stressed that the EU plan covers only people whose claims have been rejected. Britain’s Supreme Court ruled its scheme unlawful because Rwanda was not considered a safe third country, and the incoming Labour government dropped it in 2024.
Be First to Comment