Key takeaways:
- The Supreme Court left intact a ruling that cancellations of University of California research grants likely violated the First Amendment.
- Researchers’ lawyers said the administration cut off more than $324 million in University of California grants from January to June 2025.
- Only National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities grants remained at issue after a settlement involving EPA grants.
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear the Trump administration’s appeal over canceled research grants to University of California scholars, leaving in place a ruling that the terminations likely violated the researchers’ First Amendment rights.
The dispute concerns grants from the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities. The administration ended the awards after deciding that the projects did not align with President Donald Trump’s priorities, including his opposition to diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives.
The case grew out of executive orders Trump signed after taking office in January 2025. The orders directed federal agencies to bring funding into line with his policies on DEI and other subjects, including climate change and transgender rights. Lawyers for the researchers said the administration cut off more than $324 million in grants across the University of California system from January to June 2025. Some funding has since resumed, according to NBC News.
The researchers alleged that agencies searched grant applications for terms disfavored by the administration, including “diversity” and “climate change,” then canceled awards based on the results. CBS News reported that the researchers’ lawyers also identified “gender ideology” as a term used in the searches.
Grant recipients began receiving termination letters in April 2025, CBS News reported. Several months later, six University of California researchers whose grants came from the NSF, the humanities endowment and the Environmental Protection Agency sued, seeking to have their funding restored.
In June 2025, U.S. District Judge Rita Lin sided with the researchers and provisionally certified a class of University of California grant recipients affected by the executive orders. She found that the administration had terminated grants en masse for touching on prohibited subjects and that the decisions were likely based on the viewpoints the government perceived in the research. Lin ordered the administration to reinstate grants from all three agencies.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the preliminary injunction in May, agreeing that the cancellations likely amounted to unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination. The administration “has not merely exercised its power to choose the programs it funds but has instead terminated individual grants in existing programs based on the perceived viewpoints of individual speakers,” the appeals court said.
The Justice Department warned that leaving the appeals court decision in place would clear the way for taxpayer funding of research projects promoting DEI initiatives. The Supreme Court’s decision not to take the case leaves that ruling intact.
While the litigation proceeded, the researchers settled the portion of the case involving EPA grants, leaving only NSF and humanities endowment awards at issue before the Supreme Court. The administration said about $59 million remained on those grants, some of which will not expire until November 2029, CBS News reported.
The appeals court also ruled that researchers seeking to recover lost funding must bring a separate lawsuit in the Court of Federal Claims. That issue was not before the Supreme Court.
Be First to Comment