Press "Enter" to skip to content

Supreme Court leaves Maryland public gun restrictions in place

Key takeaways:

  • Maryland’s challenged restrictions cover locations including schools, public transit, parks, health care facilities, government buildings and places serving alcohol.
  • The 4th Circuit upheld all the challenged restrictions after a district court sided with gun rights plaintiffs on two categories.
  • Justice Clarence Thomas agreed the Supreme Court should not hear the broad challenge but said he was skeptical the Maryland provisions are lawful.

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a broad challenge to Maryland laws restricting where people may carry firearms, leaving the rules in place and postponing a decision on how far states can go in designating public places as gun-free zones.

The restrictions cover school grounds, public transit, state parks, museums, health care facilities, government buildings and venues for entertainment. They also apply to public demonstrations and places that sell alcohol for consumption on-site. Measures enacted in 2023 added locations including day care facilities and places where people gather for “entertainment, educational enrichment or other collective social pursuits.”

Maryland residents and four gun rights groups challenged 10 categories of restrictions under the Second Amendment. A federal district court declined to block most of them but sided with the challengers on public demonstrations and places serving alcohol. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit later upheld all the challenged restrictions. Monday’s decision leaves that ruling intact.

Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the decision not to take the case, saying the number of provisions at issue made it a poor vehicle for review. “The breadth of petitioners’ challenge would complicate our review,” he wrote. But Thomas said he was “skeptical” that Maryland’s provisions are lawful and expressed interest in a “more narrowly focused” case.

The dispute follows the Supreme Court’s 2022 ruling that recognized a Second Amendment right to carry a gun outside the home. That decision requires the government to show that a firearms restriction is consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of gun regulation. Maryland enacted some of its challenged limits the following year.

The challengers argued that the state had extended gun bans so widely that the right to carry in public had little practical meaning. “The constitutionality of these so-called ‘sensitive place’ bans is among the most critical questions facing the judiciary” after the 2022 ruling, they wrote in their petition. Their lawyers also described Maryland officials as “openly hostile” to gun rights, according to NBC News.

Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown countered that the laws fit a “rich American tradition” of barring firearms in certain locations, including places that are “confined and crowded.” He pointed to longstanding restrictions in schools, legislative assemblies, polling places and courthouses. The 4th Circuit also cited earlier Supreme Court statements that bans in schools and government buildings are permissible.

The justices have continued to consider the reach of their historical-tradition test. In 2024, they upheld a federal ban on gun possession by people subject to domestic violence restraining orders. They also struck down a Hawaii law requiring concealed-carry permit holders to obtain permission before bringing firearms onto private property open to the public. A similar Maryland provision was struck down by a lower court and was not part of this appeal, NBC News reported.

The court’s refusal to hear the Maryland case leaves the broader question of which public locations qualify as “sensitive places” unresolved.

Sources

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap